Murder vs. Right to choose

I don't usually post topics like this...but this particular one has been weighing on me big time lately for some reason.  

I guess I just really do not understand the logic/inconsistency behind some of our laws.  
I'm not going to get all in depth and go off completely on this (well, maybe I will...not making any promises), but I just have to pose the question:

What is it that makes the difference between murder and the right to choose? Is it weeks?  Days? Physically being a living breathing creature that is no longer sustained by its "host"? 

Whatever the answer is for you - does it answer the following question?  

If a woman finds out she is going to have a baby who would be less than perfect and chooses to have a late stage (third trimester) abortion.  The child is alive right?  It moves, it kicks, it hiccups, it's heart beats.  Is this murder?

Okay, so now let's say this abortion fails.  The baby is born - now it is premature in addition to its other problems and very much unwanted by the parents who had chosen to terminate it.  So the baby is alive, breathing - but struggling.  The baby is carried off to a room where it is left to die.  Sometimes given the courtesy of a nurse or tech who will hold it till it dies, other times just left on a cold table to die by itself.  No medical intervention is given to this child that was born - entered the world - alive!  Is this murder?  

What about the woman or teenager who has a baby but gets scared or decides she can't deal with it so she abandons the newborn baby that is only minutes or hours old.  Perhaps she leaves it in a field...or in a trash can.  The newborn baby dies.  Is this murder?  If so, how is it different than the act above with the same outcome of a child the same age?

What about the mother of the two year old who is throwing temper tantrums every day...she just can't deal with it anymore so she terminates her childs life.  Is this murder?  

What about the mother of a teenager who is doing drugs and living a destructive lifestyle?  Or maybe just being an ungrateful brat?  She terminates that teenagers life.  Is that murder? 

My point is: what exactly is the point, the defining moment when we decide a life being terminated is murder vs the woman's right to choose?  Isn't terminating a teenagers life still the woman's "right to choose"?  I mean if our laws make it clear that a beating heart isn't the defining factor why is that not a woman's "right to choose?"  Apparently it isn't even that having breathed their first breath is the defining factor.  So where exactly is that distinction?  Is it minutes, hours, weeks after a child is born that we decide it's suddenly a living human worthy of living?  Is it okay to terminate a life that is an hour old because a woman decided while she was pregnant that she didn't want the child to be born?  So why not then when that child is 15 - using the same argument?

I guess I just don't understand - how can we prosecute the woman who throws her 1 hour old baby into a trash can, but not prosecute the woman or doctors who allow a child who was born from a failed abortion as being murderers but instead PROTECT them from prosecution.  

I don't get it...I guess I never will.  


  

Comments

That's one reason I did not vote for Obama. I don't understand how people that claimed to be christians not see this and voted him for his change" policy, over God's directive. To think that he may replace two supreme court justices during his presidency makes me wonder where our country is heading.
Stephanie said…
I honestly am pro life, however ultimately it is the person who chooses and makes the decision. Nobody makes someone have an abortion. Everywhere else in life we are accountable for our decisions..I mean why do they have cars that can go 180 mph when it is illegal to drive over 65 in some instances. My point is, each person makes their decision, even the wrong ones...and when judgment happens, they have to answer, I doubt God will say, 'Oh it's bad you had an abortion, but that ole' American Government said it was okay, so you can go through the pearly gates.' C'mon! Don't misunderstand me....I think abortion is awful excuse for lack of planning and is just plain wrong, but thankfully, it's not my decision to make.
Diana said…
ummmm - very good blog entry - Jim and I just read this one together - you make some really good points. Bottomline in my opinion and I believe in God's directives - a life, is a life, is a life....He knit me in my mother's womb....only He can giveth and only He can take away.

Popular posts from this blog

Tall tales...and other poop related news

Fall visit to Aroboretum